This study employs a time-varying parameter vector autoregression (TVP-VAR) to quantify dynamic connectedness and directional volatility spillovers between seven critical mineral ETF portfolios and macro-financial variables (energy market, carbon emissions, market sentiment, and global infrastructure). The analysis uses daily data from 2013-05-01 to 2023-05-02 and distinguishes pre- and post-COVID-19 periods to capture structural breaks during the energy transition. Findings reveal ESG scores significantly influence spillovers, with higher-ESG portfolios more likely to act as net transmitters, while energy and carbon-emission futures tend to be net receivers. The COVID-19 episode induced substantial shifts in transmission roles, and ESG-based risk links emerge as a key systemic factor for investors seeking hedging and diversification in a dynamic macro-financial network. This work contributes by leveraging ETF data to reflect investable risk and by linking ESG performance to a portfolio’s directional role within a broader connectedness framework.
速读内容
TVP-VAR framework and data integration
Uses seven critical mineral ETFs (LIT, PICK, VAW, COPX, IYM, REMX, VXF) and macro-financial variables (WTI, VIX, CEF, GII) to map dynamic spillovers with daily log-returns over 2013–2023 .
Applies the TVP-VAR framework and GFEVD to identify net givers vs receivers and track how connections evolve, especially across structural breaks like COVID-19 .
Key result: VAW, IYM, PICK, COPX, and LIT are major net transmitters; WTI and CEF are primary net receivers; COVID-19 shifts are evident in transmission roles .
ESG linkage to spillovers and network roles
Portfolio
ESG Score
NET Directional Connectedness (NET)
IYM
6.55
+16.91%
VAW
6.48
+17.32%
REMX
5.07
-6.43%
Spearman correlation between ESG scores and NET is 0.8857 (p = 0.0033), indicating higher ESG portfolios tend to transmit more volatility .
Univariate regression: a 1-unit ESG increase associates with about +15.94% NET (R2 = 0.901, p = 0.0038), suggesting ESG strength enhances systemic influence in the network .
COVID-19 impact on transmission structure
Figure 6 and Table 10 show a heterogeneous, time-varying spillover pattern with shifting sender/receiver roles around the pandemic .
Global infrastructure investment (GII) moves from net receiver pre-COVID to net giver post-COVID, reflecting a reorientation of macro-financial linkages during the energy transition .
The rolling connectedness (TCI ~ 70.68% during the pandemic) indicates elevated co-movement and systemic risk concentration in crisis periods .
Implications for investors and risk management
Identifying net givers/receivers informs hedging and diversification strategies under evolving regime shifts, especially during extreme events. The results emphasize incorporating ESG-related risk channels into portfolio construction and stress testing.